DEVELOPMENT OF THE CONCEPT OF NATIONAL CHARACTER WITHIN «CULTURE AND PERSONALITY» SCHOOL: CRITICISM AND TRANSFORMATION
DOI: 10.23951/2307-6119-2021-3-127-138
The article is devoted to such a topical and controversial phenomenon as national character. The article examines the development of the concept of national character during the existence of “culture and personality” school. The main problematic of the concept was connected with its validity and application not only within the framework of cultural anthropology, but also in sociology and psychology. During the early “culture and personality” school (1927–1945) E. Sapir and R. Benedict laid the foundations of the school, as well as the main directions of the methodological development of the concept — such approaches as the “basic personality structure” by A. Kardiner and “modal personality” by K. Du Bois, the problem of research of a national character in the context of the reliability of the results and work with complex social structures and nations in general is raised. Within the framework of the early period, the influence of the Second World War on the development of the concept of national character is shown and the reasons for the demand for research within the framework of the national character are indicated. In the later period of the school's activity (1946–1969), there is an increase in criticism from sociologists and psychologists not only of a national character, but also of “culture and personality” approach for the lack of empirical data. During this period, special attention is paid to the development of approaches that study the personal characteristics of representatives of nations. At the same time, a methodological basis for cross-cultural research is being formed and the groundwork for creating cross-cultural psychology is being formed. Throughout the article, two waves of criticism of the national character are presented, the result of which in the late 1960s was the denial of the existence of national character by a significant number of scientists as a phenomenon of national life, and “culture and personality” school experienced a crisis and fell into decay. Various assessments of the studies of that time on the development of national character within the framework of the “culture and personality” school are shown, as well as proposals for a way out of the methodological crisis.
Keywords: national character, culture and personality, anthropology, modal personality, basic personality structure
References:
Anisimova N. N. Nacional’nyj harakter i nacional’nyj mentalitet [National character and national mindset], in Vestnik donskogo agrarnogo universiteta [Bulletin of Don agrarian university]. 2019. No. 1–2 (31). Pp. 5–10.
Bateson G. (1942) Morale and national character, in Civilian morale: Second yearbook of the Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues. Ed. by G. B. Watson. Houghton Mifflin. Pp. 71–91.
Bell D. (1968) National character revisited: a proposal for renegotiating the concept, in The study of personality; an interdisciplinary appraisal. Ed. by E. Norbeck, D. R. Price-Williams, W. M. McCord. Holt, Rinehart and Winston. Pp. 103–120.
Benedict R. (1989) Patterns of culture. Houghton Mifflin. 326 p.
Chetvertakova Zh. V. Zakonomernosti formirovanija nacional’nogo haraktera [The patterns of national character formation], in Analitika kul’turologii [Analytics of cultural studies], 2011. No. 1 (19). Pp. 222–229.
Du Bois C. (1944) The People Of Alor. The University of Minnesota Press. 654 p.
Duijker H. C. J. (1959) National stereotypes and national character, in Acta psychologica, 15. Pp. 527–529.
Eller J. D. (2019) Psychological anthropology for the 21st century. Routledge. Pp. 28–35.
Farber M. L. (1955) The study of national character: 1955, in Journal of social issues, 11:2. Pp. 52–56.
Fromm E. (1969) Escape from freedom. Avon Books. 342 p.
Fyfe H. (1946) The illusion of national character. Watts & Co. 157 p.
Gorer G. (1956) The Concept of National Character, in Personality in nature, society, and culture. Ed. by C. Kluckhohn, H. A. Murray. Alfred A. Knopf, 2-nd edition. Pp. 246–259.
Hennessy B. C. (1962) Psycho-cultural studies of national character: relevances of international relations, in Background, 6:1/3. Pp. 27–49.
Hertz F. (1944) Nationality in history and politics. Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co, Ltd. 417 p.
Hoebel E. A. (1967) Anthropological perspectives on national character, in The annals of the American academy of political and social science, 307. Pp. 1–7.
Honigmann J. J. (1959) Psychocultural studies, in Biennial review of anthropology, edited by B. J. Siegel. Stanford University Press. Pp. 67–106.
Honigmann J. J., Preston R. J. (1965) Supplement: Recent Developments in Culture and Personality, in The annals of the American academy of political and social science, 354. Pp. 153–162.
Hsu F. L. K. (1980) Margaret Mead and psychological anthropology, in American anthropologist, 82:2. Pp. 349–350.
Inkeles A. (1997) National character: a psycho-social perspective. Transaction Publishers. 426 p.
Inkeles A., Levinson D. J. (1969) National character: the study of modal personality and sociocultural systems, in The Handbook Of Social Psychology. Addison-Wesley publishing company, 2-nd edition. Pp. 418–506.
Kaplan B. (1961) Personality study and culture, in Studying personality cross-culturally. Ed. by B. Kaplan. Harper & Row Publishers. Pp. 301–311.
Kardiner A. (1939) The individual and his society. Columbia university press. 503 p.
Klineberg O. (1944) A science of national character, in American scientist, 32:4. Pp. 273–285.
Klineberg O. (1974) Recent studies of national character, in Culture and personality. Ed. by S. S. Sargent, M. W. Smith. Cooper Square Publishers Inc. Pp. 127–141.
Koptseva N. P., Reznikova K. V. Metodologicheskie vozmozhnosti antropologicheskoj shkoly «kul’tura-i-lichnost’» dlja sovremennych rossijskich social’no-kul’turnych issledovanij [Methodological possibilities of «culture and personality» anthropological school for contemporary Russian social and cultural studies], in Sovremennye problemy nauki i obrazovanija [Modern problems of science and education]. 2013. No. 4. Pp. 388–396.
Kustova L. S. Nacional’nyj harakter kak rezul’tat tvorchestva naroda. Uchebnoe posobie [National character as a result of people’s creativity. Tutorial]. М.: Izdatel’stvo fakul’teta zhurnalistiki MGU [The faculty of journalism press of MSU], 2002. 118 p.
Kustova L. S. Tajna nacional’nogo haraktera [The mystery of national character]. М.: Izdatel’stvo IKАR, 2003. 164 p.
LeVine R. A. (1963) Culture and personality, in Biennial review of anthropology, 3. Pp. 107–145.
Lindesmith A. R., Strauss A. L. (1950) A critique of culture-personality writings, in American Sociological Review, 15:5. Pp. 586–600.
Lindholm C. (2008) Culture and identity: the history, theory, and practice of psychological anthropology. Oneworld Publications. 446 p.
Lur’e S. V. Utoptannaja doroga skvoz’ tiomnyj les. Vvedenie v jetnopsihologiju [Trampled path through a dark forest. Introduction to ethnopsychology]. Sankt-Peterbur [Saint-Petersburg], 2017. 261 p.
Martindale D. (1967) The sociology of national character, in The annals of the American academy of political and social science, 370:1. Pp. 30–35.
Mead M. (1953) National character, in Anthropology today : an encyclopedic inventory / Ed. by A. L. Kroeber. University of Chicago Press. Pp. 642–667.
Mishina M. M., Ravilova М. V. Shkola «kul’tura-i-lichnost’» [«Culture and personality» school], in Sem’ja i lichnost’: problemy vzaimodejstvija [Family and personality: communication problems]. 2017. No. 7. Pp. 66–73.
Neiburg F., Goldman M. (1998) Anthropology and politics in studies of national character, in Cultural Anthropology, 13:1. Pp. 56–81.
Riesman D. (1953) Psychological types and national character: an informal commentary, in American quarterly, 5:4. Pp. 325–343.
Sapir E. (1934) Personality, in Encyclopedia of the social sciences, 12. Pp. 85–87.
Sapir E. (1934) The emergence of the concept of personality in a study of culture, in Journal of social psychology, 5. Pp. 408–415.
Singer M. (1961) A survey of culture and personality theory and research, in Studying personality cross-culturally. Ed. by B. Kaplan. Harper & Row. Pp. 9–92.
Sulzbach W. (1943) National consciousness. American Council on Public Affairs. 1943. p. 34.
Wallace A. F. C. (1967) Culture and personality. Random House. 230 p.
Wallace A. F. C., Fogelson R. D. (1961) Culture and Personality, in Biennial review of anthropology, 2. Pp. 42–78.
( 748.28 kB ) 
( 687.75 kB )
Issue: 3, 2021
Series of issue: Issue 3
Rubric: ANTHROPOLOGY
Pages: 127 — 138
Downloads: 625