GENETIC AND GENEALOGICAL RESEARCH OF SOME KHAKASS CLANS
DOI: 10.23951/2307-6119-2022-2-127-148
The article considers the interpretation of personal haplotypes of the modern ethnic Khakass with regard to their private genealogies. During DNA testing of the Khakass’ Y-chromosome, different marker panels of haplotypes were obtained, which were used to determine haplogroups, and most importantly – to compare with personal oral and archival-documentary genealogies of donors in order to verify kinship. The novelty of this genetic-genealogical (genetealogical) study involves correlating eight private Khakass surnames (Ugdyzhekov, Shulberekov, Sagataev, Borgoyakov, Sandaraev, Tarkhanov, Torosov, Mainagashev) with objective genetic markers of the Y-chromosome obtained from ten donors. Two 37-marker STR-haplotypes of the Tarkhanovs belonging to donors from the Khakass subethnos of the Kyzyl people (the Sharypovo District of the Krasnoyarsk Region), as well as the Beltir 37-marker haplotype of the Torosovs, are published for the first time. Six Khakass haplotypes were fully attributed (up to the full name). Most of DNA tests were carried out in the American Commercial Company “Family Tree DNA” (Houston, Texas, USA) for haplotypes of different lengths – from 12 to 111 STR markers. For all the presented Khakass haplotypes, it is necessary to perform genome-wide sequencing of the Y-chromosome to detect SNP mutations up to the definition of familial terminal snips. Since the Beltirs’ genealogies are the deepest among the Khakass subethnoses, going back to the 16th century, it is primary to haplotype and snip male descendants from the Beltir families/seoks. In the future, this will allow us to apply the new methodology extensively – for example, for mapping/identification of Khakass kinships/seoks in the form of phylogenetic trees (modeled on the human Y-chromosome haplogroup tree YFull YTree). The currently available anonymous population-genetic data obtained by scientists from the Laboratory of Evolutionary Genetics of the Research Institute of Medical Genetics of Tomsk National Research Medical Center are unsuitable for calibration of reconstructed documentary genealogies, and therefore the full potential of the new verification methodology remains undiscovered.
Keywords: DNA, genetic genealogy, haplotype, Khakass DNA project, genealogy, subclade, revision tale, Khakas, haplogroup, seok
References:
Ilumäe A.-M. et al. Human Y Chromosome Haplogroup N: A Non-trivial Time-Resolved Phylogeography that Cuts across Language Families // The American Journal of Human Genetics. 2016. V. 99. P. 163–173. URL: https://www.academia.edu/32075863/ARTICLE_Human_Y_Chromosome_Haplogroup_N_A_Non_trivial_Time_Resolved_Phylogeography_that_Cuts_across_Language_Families , https://www.cell.com/cms/10.1016/j.ajhg.2016.05.025/attachment/a3b91fe9-e6b7-41baabbc-01f6b7f3e299/mmc1 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Borgoyakov M. I. O proiskhozhdenii i rasprostranenii hakasskih familij [About the origin and distribution of Khakass surnames] // Uchyonye zapiski HakNIIYALI. Vyp. XVII. Abakan, 1972. S. 235–241. URL: https://nbdrx.ru/pdf/bx0000062.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Borgoyakov P. Ya. Tireң kichigde. Sakyj – moya derevnya [Saky – my village]. Abakan, 2021. 192 s.
Butanaev V. Ya. Istoricheskaya onomastika Yuzhnoj Sibiri: uchebno-metodicheskij kompleks po discipline: kurs lekcij [Historical onomastics of Southern Siberia: an educational and methodological complex for the discipline: course of lectures] / V. Ya. Butanaev, K. M. Torbostaev. Abakan, 2016. 220 s.
Butanaev V. Ya. Proiskhozhdenie i rasselenie hakasskih seokov / Etnicheskaya istoriya narodov Yuzhnoj Sibiri i Central’noj Azii [Origin and settlement of the Khakass Seok / Ethnic history of the peoples of Southern Siberia and Central Asia]; otv. red. B. R. Zoriktuev. Novosibirsk, 1993. S. 235–263. URL: https://nbdrx.ru/pdf/staty/ax0000045.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Butanaev V. Ya. Proiskhozhdenie hakasskih rodov i familij [Origin of Khakass families and surnames]. Abakan, 1994. 92 s. URL: http://nbdrx.ru/pdf/bx0000127.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Butanaev V. Ya., Butanaeva I. I. My rodom iz Hongoraya. Hakasskie mify, legendy i predaniya [We come from Hongorai. Khakass myths, legends and legends] / Otv. red. B. R. Zoriktuev. Abakan, 2010. 240 s.
Volkov V. G. Obshchie geneticheskie linii tyurkskih narodov [Common genetic lines of the Turkic peoples] // Korennye narody Sibiri: istoriya, tradicii i sovremennost’: materialy regional’noj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem (Novosibirsk, 12 oktyabrya 2017 g.). Abakan, 2018. S. 40–44.
Volkov V. G., Har’kov V. N., Shtygasheva O. V., Stepanov V. A. Geneticheskoe issledovanie hakasskih i teleutskih seokov. Sravnitel’naya harakteristika po dannym markerov Y-hromosomy [Genetic study of Khakass and Teleut seok. Comparative characteristics according to Y-chromosome markers] // Kul’tura kak sistema v istoricheskom kontekste: opyt Zapadno-Sibirskih arheologo-etnograficheskih soveshchanij. Materialy XV Mezhdunarodnoj Zapadno-Sibirskoj arheologoetnograficheskoj konferencii. Tomsk, 19–21 maya 2010 g. Tomsk, 2010. S. 403–405. URL: http://trog.narod.ru/articles/sook.htm , http://vital.lib.tsu.ru/vital/access/manager/Repository/vtls:000397210 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Genofond tatar: istoriko-geneticheskoe issledovanie. Gaplogruppy Y-hromosomy [The gene pool of the Tatars: historical and genetic research. Y-chromosome haplogroups] / M. M. Akchurin i [dr.]. Kazan’, 2021. 112 s. URL: http://xn--80aimpg.xn--80aagie6cnnb.xn--p1ai/uploads/libraries/original/60e56f340d1760812a2d37b873e802db24f8d0e4.pdf?1640952546 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Blizhajshij obshchij predok russkih i hakasov po dannym DNK-genealogii [The closest common ancestor of Russians and Khakas according to DNA genealogy] // Materialy VI Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii “Narody i kul’tury Sayano-Altaya i sopredel’nyh territorij”. Abakan, 2019. S. 79–83. URL: http://haknii.ru/files/Materiali%206%20Mezhdunarodnoy%20konferencii_compressed.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Genetiko-genealogicheskoe (genetealogicheskoe) issledovanie roda Nilogovyh (na materiale DNK autosom i Y-hromosomy) [Genetic and genealogical (genetealogical) study of the genus Nilogovoi (based on the DNA of autosomes and Y-chromosomes)] // Uchyonye zapiski Minusinskogo kraevedcheskogo muzeya im. N. M. Mart’yanova. Vyp. № 3. Minusinsk, 2021. S. 161–212. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=47456561 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Dokumental’naya rekonstrukciya patrilinejnoj rodoslovnoj V. M. Torosova [Documentary reconstruction of V. M. Torosov’s patrilineal genealogy] // Genesis: istoricheskie issledovaniya. 2022. № 1. S. 80–88. URL: https://e-notabene.ru/hr/article_34938.html (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Dokumental’naya rekonstrukciya rodoslovnoj S. D. Majnagasheva (k 135-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya) [Documentary reconstruction of the genealogy of S. D. Mainagashev (to the 135th anniversary of his birth)] // Tomskij zhurnal lingvisticheskih i antropologicheskih issledovanij. 2021. № 4. S. 148–158. URL: https://ling.tspu.edu.ru/files/ling/PDF/articles/nilogov_a._s._148_158_4_34_2021.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Massovye genealogicheskie istochniki po kochevym inorodcam Minusinskogo uezda XIX veka v fondah Nacional’nogo arhiva Respubliki Hakasiya i arhiva goroda Minusinska [Mass genealogical sources on nomadic foreigners of the Minusinsk district of the XIX century in the funds of the National Archive of the Republic of Khakassia and the archive of the city of Minusinsk] // Nauchno-istoricheskij elektronnyj zhurnal arhivnyh uchrezhdenij SFO “Sibirskij arhiv”. 2021. № 3. S. 45–53. URL: https://archivesiberia-journal.nso.ru/sites/archivesiberia-journal.nso.ru/wodby_files/files/page_325/nilogov_a._s._-_na_sayt_0.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Mitohondrial’nye linii sovremennyh etnicheskih hakasov [Mitochondrial lines of modern ethnic Khakas] // Uchyonye zapiski Minusinskogo kraevedcheskogo muzeya im. N. M. Mart’yanova. 2020. Vyp. 2. S. 151–164. URL: https://xn----8sbahmlpvellw0ag7lzb.xn--p1ai/files/%D0%9C%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%B5%D1%82%20%D0%A3%D1%87%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%B5%20%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BF%D0%B8%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%202020.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Nauchnaya verifikaciya hakasskih rodoslovnyh predanij: ot mifo- i etnogenealogii k DNK-genealogii [Scientific verification of Khakass ancestral traditions: from mytho- and ethnogenealogy to DNA genealogy] // Genesis: istoricheskie issledovaniya. 2020. № 1. S. 57–65. URL: http://e-notabene.ru/hr/article_29539.html (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S. Snipovanie kak imenovanie (antiyazykovaya metodologiya v pomoshch’ DNK-genealogii) [Sniping as naming (anti-language methodology to help DNA genealogy)] // Litera. 2016. № 1. S. 18–25. [El. resurs]. URL: http://e-notabene.ru/fil/article_17670.html (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Nilogov A. S., Pajor E. V. Proiskhozhdenie hakasskogo roda Majnagashevyh: ustnye predaniya i DNK-genealogicheskie dannye [The origin of the Khakass Mainagashev family: oral traditions and DNA genealogical data] // Istoricheskij format. 2020. № 3. S. 8–17. URL: http://histformat.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/2020-3.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Novikova L. M. Struktura genofonda shorcev i hakasov po autosomnym STR-markeram i markeram Y-hromosomy [The structure of the Shorets and Khakas gene pool by autosomal STR markers and Y-chromosome markers]. Vypusknaya kvalifikacionnaya rabota bakalavra. Tomsk, 2017. 71 s. [El. resurs]. URL: http://vital.lib.tsu.ru/vital/access/manager/Repository/vital:4172 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Pajor E. V. Replika po povodu stat’i: Pilipenko A. S., Trapezov R. O., Polos’mak N. V. Paleogeneticheskoe issledovanie nositelej pazyrykskoj kul’tury iz mogil’nika Ak-Alaha-1 (Gornyj Altaj) [Remark about the article: Pilipenko A. S., Trapezov R. O., Polosmak N. V. Paleogenetic study of the carriers of the Pazyryk culture from the Ak-Alakha-1 burial ground (Gorny Altai)] // Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii. 2015. № 4. S. 144–150 // Istoricheskij format. 2019. № 3–4. S. 99–102. URL: http://histformat.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/2019-3-4.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Patachakov K. M. Rodovoj sostav i narodnye predaniya o proiskhozhdenii bel’tirov [Ancestral composition and folk legends about the origin of the Beltirs] // Uchyonye zapiski HakNIIYALI. Vyp. VII. Abakan, 1959. S. 127–134. URL: https://nbdrx.ru/pdf/bx0000042.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Pilipenko A. S., Trapezov R. O., Polos’mak N. V. Paleogeneticheskoe issledovanie nositelej pazyrykskoj kul’tury iz mogil’nika Ak-Alaha-1 (Gornyj Altaj) [Paleogenetic study of the carriers of the Pazyryk culture from the Ak-Alakha-1 burial ground (Gorny Altai)] // Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii. 2015. № 4. S. 144–150. URL: https://docplayer.ru/139309467-Paleogeneticheskoe-issledovanie-nositeley-pazyrykskoy-kultury-iz-mogilnika-ak-alaha-1-gornyy-altay.html (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Potapov L. P. Proiskhozhdenie i formirovanie hakasskoj narodnosti [Origin and formation of the Khakass nationality]. Abakan, 1957. 308 s. URL: https://vk.com/doc243238609_445630150?hash=a616084c4dbd8d613b&dl=66681776f37ea3e039 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Tyotushkin E. Ya. Geneticheskaya genealogiya: istoriya i metodologiya [Genetic genealogy: history and methodology] // Genetika. 2011. T. 47. № 5. S. 581–596. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=16339657 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Tyotushkin E. Ya. Geneticheskie aspekty genealogii [Genetic aspects of genealogy] // Genetika. 2011. T. 47. № 11. S. 1451–1472. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=17056880 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N. Markery Y-hromosomy v populyacionnoj genetike: fundamental’nye i prikladnye rezul’taty etnogenomnyh issledovanij [Y-chromosome markers in population genetics: fundamental and applied results of ethnogenomic studies] // Genetika. 2021. T. 57. № 9. S. 981–994. URL: https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=46350988 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N. Struktura i filogeografiya genofonda korennogo naseleniya Sibiri po markeram Y-hromosomy [Structure and phylogeography of the gene pool of the indigenous population of Siberia by Y-chromosome markers]: Dissertaciya... doktora biologicheskih nauk. Tomsk, 2012. 397 s.
Har’kov V. N., Zarubin A. A., Vagajceva K. V., Radzhabov M. O., Novikova L. M., Valihova L. V., Hitrinskaya I. Yu., Stepanov V. A. Y-hromosoma kak instrument dlya DNK-identifikacii i opredeleniya populyacionnoj prinadlezhnosti [Y-chromosome as a tool for DNA identification and determination of population affiliation] // Genetika. 2020. T. 56. № 9. S. 1065–1074. URL: https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=43181768 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N., Novikova L. M., Shtygasheva O. V., Ageeva E. S., Volkov V. G., Hitrinskaya I. Yu., Stepanov V. A. Analiz rodoplemennoj struktury hakasov po markeram Y-hromosomy [Analysis of the tribal structure of Khakas by Y-chromosome markers] // Medicinskaya genetika. 2017. T. 16. № 12. S. 35–38. URL: https://www.medgen-journal.ru/jour/article/view/355/271 (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N., Novikova L. M., Shtygasheva O. V., Volkov V. G., Hitrinskaya I. Yu., Stepanov V. A. Analiz rodoplemennoj struktury hakasov po markeram Y-hromosomy [Analysis of the tribal structure of Khakas by Y-chromosome markers] // Genetika cheloveka i patologiya: sbornik nauchnyh trudov / pod red. V. A. Stepanova. Vyp. 11. Tomsk, 2017. S. 59–60. URL: http://medgenetics.ru/UserFile/File/Doc/Conference%202017/Genetika%20cheloveka_vol_11_-1-110.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N., Novikova L. M., Shtygasheva O. V., Luzina F. A., Hitrinskaya I. Yu., Volkov V. G., Stepanov V. A. Genofond hakasov i shorcev po markeram Y-hromosomy: obshchie komponenty i geneticheskaya struktura rodov [The gene pool of Khakas and Shors by Y-chromosome markers: common components and genetic structure of clans] // Genetika. 2020. T. 56. № 7. S. 826–833. URL: https://sciencejournals.ru/cgi/getPDF.pl?jid=genrus&year=2020&vol=56&iss=7&file=GenRus2007007Kharkov.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Har’kov V. N., Hamina K. V., Medvedeva O. F., Shtygasheva O. V., Stepanov V. A. Raznoobrazie genofonda hakasov: vnutrietnicheskaya differenciaciya i struktura gaplogrupp Y-hromosomy [Diversity of the Khakas gene pool: intraethnic differentiation and structure of Y-chromosome haplogroups] // Molekulyarnaya biologiya. 2011. T. 45. № 3. S. 446–458. URL: http://www.medgenetics.ru/UserFile/File/Doc/Evolution%20Doc/Kharkov-MolBiol-2011-45(3)-446-458-Y-Khakas.pdf (Data obrashch. 01.02.2022).
Shtygasheva O. V., Ageeva E. S., Har’kov V. N., Stepanov V. A. Geny i bolezni hakasov [Genes and diseases of Khakas]. Krasnoyarsk, 2010. 296 s.
Yarilov A. A. Kyzyl’cy i ih hozyajstvo [Kyzyl people and their economy]. Yur’ev, 1899. 366 s. (Byloe i nastoyashchee sibirskih inorodcev. Materialy dlya ih izucheniya. Vyp. 3). URL: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/JA/Yarilov_A_A_Kyzylcy_i_ih_hozyajstvo.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 01.02.2022).
( 1.65 MB ) 
( 1.38 MB )
Issue: 2, 2022
Series of issue: Issue 2
Rubric: ANTHROPOLOGY
Pages: 127 — 148
Downloads: 949